Prepare to be whisked away to a world of opulence and old-world charm! I recently had the pleasure of staying at a hotel that embodies the essence of New York's rich history and extravagant lifestyle. But is it worth the hype?
This iconic hotel, nestled in the NoMad neighborhood, boasts a fascinating history. Once the residence of socialite Charlotte Goodridge, it later transformed into a bank and then an Italianate mansion. The lobby alone is a portal to the past, adorned with cabinets of crystals, plush velvet sofas, and walls resembling a Rousseau painting. The service matches this decadence, offering a personal butler to cater to every guest's need.
The renowned Swedish designer Martin Brudnizki left his playful mark on the interiors. From pleated pink silk walls with tassels from a centuries-old American tassel maker to lamp sconces adorned with birds and hands, every detail is meticulously crafted. Bevelled glass and sparkling chandeliers evoke a romantic, bygone era. And the rooms? Well, they're a delightful surprise depending on which side of the hotel you're on. Expect vibrant, Gatsby-esque vibes with either pink and jungle-themed or forest-green pastoral wallpaper.
The hotel comprises a 24-story glass tower, a modern addition built on an old carriage house site, and the original mansion overlooking the iconic Fifth Avenue. All rooms are a vibrant, modern take on the Gatsby era, with a tablet controlling lights, curtains, and even the TV. The rooms are spacious, with cozy chairs and lovely views, while the tower's studio suites resemble chic New York apartments. The mansion suites are a maximalist's dream, featuring tasselled lamps, fresh flowers, and ceiling lights dangling from gold stars. A green room divider adds a playful touch, and each room has a hidden 'Maxi Bar' with complimentary treats and a mini cabinet of goodies from the hotel's fine dining restaurant, Café Carmellini.
Speaking of Café Carmellini, it's the hotel's bustling social hub. Run by chef Andrew, it offers a seasonal menu divided into crudo, appetizers, pasta, and mains, with a particular emphasis on fresh pasta. The wine list is extensive, boasting 15,000 bottles! For evening drinks, the Portrait Bar is the place to be, with cocktails inspired by geography and stylish gallery walls of portraits.
While the hotel lacks a pool or spa, it offers event spaces with unique histories, like the former bank vault now used for wine tastings. There's also a gym, and butlers can arrange sessions with local fitness partners. Located in the heart of NoMad, the hotel is within walking distance of many attractions, including the Empire State Building, Madison Square Garden, and Broadway.
But here's where it gets controversial: is this level of luxury worth the price tag? With room rates starting at £741, it's a significant investment for a night's stay. Yet, for those seeking an immersive experience in New York's glamorous past, it might just be the perfect choice.
What do you think? Would you splurge on a stay at this decadent hotel, or do you prefer more understated accommodations? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
